Serving Metro Vancouver. When it comes to choosing the best wood, it can be a tough choice, as there are pros and very little cons to each. Douglas fir still has great qualities, resistance to rot and insects, and should last at least 5 years+. Model #RC6C42. It’s also the most affordable option! Select an option Pine Sitka Spruce Douglas Fir Western Hemlock Yellow Cedar. That look is what you want for your landscape beds. Made in the USA from naturally rot- and insect-resistant North American Cedar. Last year I spent hours evaluating lumber options for our garden boxes. ... we work with a team of skilled mills that can help you achieve the custom pattern you desire or need in Western Red Cedar, Alaskan Yellow Cedar, Douglas Fir and just about any other hard or softwood. (Amazon) If you have budget considerations, Douglas fir may be the perfect choice for you. spruce/pine/fir) for raised beds… Homemade Milk Paint (see several different recipes below) Homemade Beeswax and Jojoba Oil Wood Conditioner (my favorite) Raw linseed oil is an all-natural, eco-safe wood preservative that is fairly inexpensive and can be purchased in organic forms. Spruce, fir and arborvitae are pyramid-shaped evergreens that may cover a circle 30 feet in diameter when they reach full maturity. For perennial garden beds and landscaping zones that don’t feature a lot of annual plants, this can help plants recover and bounce back stronger each spring. The main difference here is that it is 2" thick (vs 1" on the cedar). Pressure-treated wood should not be used for any indoor applications. You want to be able to work in your garden beds without stepping on them. Cedar – Another rot-resistant wood, cedar can last 10-15 years and looks gorgeous. Resistant or very resistant: old-growth bald cypress, catalpa, cedar (either eastern or western red cedar), black cherry, chestnut, junipers, honey locust, white oak, old-growth redwood, sassafras, and black walnut. So about $4.25 on screws for each raised bed. But, it’s expensive. These options are typically more affordable than redwood or cedar, though not quite as durable. $89.95 - $299.95. I know the wood will rot, but i dont mind swapping out the wood every 3 or 4 years. Location: Seattle, WA. It is an economical type of wood that suits low-budget users. Pine is the logical choice for most people when choosing lumber for raised beds. If you're willing to, you can spend more on cedar or redwood, but we figured since this is our first time building a raised garden bed, we'll try the Douglas fir out! For raised bed construction we recommend the “STK” Western Red Cedar 2X6, 2X8, and 4X4 from the price list. Both cedar and fir wood are readily available, inexpensive materials for building fences, but they have very different properties. Take Doug Fir beams for example. Douglas fir wood is typically a light brown color with a hint of red and/or yellow. Cedar boards, .5 inches x 4 inches x 8 feet. According to the writers from Greenhouse Today, fir is a hardy wood … This means it won’t suffocate new plant growth and germination at the same rate different types of mulch will. A lining can make an BTW I was “introduced” to you on Garden Fork podcasts. Wooden planters, built out of untreated wood raised bed garden materials, will probably last much longer than you think. Avoid non-porous plastic, as it can retain too much water and discourage beneficial insects and worms. Douglas fir is another type of wood commonly used in garden planter boxes and raised bed assemblies. Start with a clean surface. AVAILABILITY: 2x4 surfaced decking; 2x6 surfaced decking Raised beds are a great idea because they protect growing plants from the scuffs and kicks of passersby while allowing the soil to warm faster in the springtime, generating an earlier crop. It is a native species that only grows in U.S. Department of Agriculture plant hardiness zones 5 and 6, and although not a true fir, it is the most rot-resistant of the firs. Douglas fir boards hold up well for three to six years when in direct contact with the ground. How long will untreated wood last in raised beds? Overall, pressure treated lumber resists rot and insects; however, it … Douglas Fir. Popular softwood lumber includes Douglas fir, pine, spruce, and juniper. Wood is a very versatile material for vegetable gardens. I am building a raised bed for asparagus, a bed I hope to exist for 20-plus years. Aesthetics can make a major difference in the curb appeal of your home, so decide which color will suit your home the best. 1. More noticeable with the large nuggets, there are small chunks of wood from the tree that get broken up and mixed in with the bark - but the medium nuggets are more uniform. Examples of softwood trees are cedar, Douglas fir, juniper, pine, redwood, spruce, and yew. Outside of cedar there are several other varieties of wood that rank high for raised garden beds. Redwood or Black Locust – Definitely the best option for raised garden boxes in terms of longevity because they are naturally rot-resistant and have been known to last up to 20 years. Gardening catalogs are full of raised bed kits which they claim will get you ‘set up in minutes’ and enjoying your own fresh vegetables without all the hassle of digging or weeding. Pressure treated was, of course, out. Among those are Eastern Hemlock, Douglas Fir, Redwood, Walnut, Pine and Spruce. Raised beds are a popular option, especially in areas with naturally poor or rocky soils or small spaces, and they are used to ease the pain of bending all the way to the ground to garden. Although fir species vary in their rot resistance, all will decay to the point of needing to be replaced within several years. I have read that Douglas fir is moderately rot resistant, so I'm thinking it could be an option and not rot to quickly. Our pecky landscape timbers put the 100% natural decay resistance of Incense Cedar to work. ... To me this made this tree good wood for cedar shakes and bad wood for gardening. Fine dark fir gives you that look that stands out in a neighborhood. Our employees have decades of building industry experience and are here to help you with your project. Raised bed kits have become popular with Internet suppliers and local garden centers. Doug Fir! Top 5 Natural Wood Sealers and Conditioners. Douglas fir is the strongest and most valuable construction wood on my place. Softwoods are frequently used as building materials. Timbers and beams – Textured or smooth (S4S), Structural strength, Better priced than Cedar, Splits and checks are part of natural beauty and character. Because of this, folks frequently ask us about the best type of wood to use for their planter boxes and raised garden beds. A smooth product for a finished look in your flower bed. What is the safest choice for raised garden beds? Find My Store. It is readily available locally, and although it is largely grown in the western states, the trees are often planted in New Hampshire. Optional planter bottoms provide soil drainage for gardens on roof-tops, driveways and parking lots. Much like juniper, cedar is naturally high in aromatic oils that repel insects and slow decay, but offers a more refined look with a silky, strawberry-blonde grain. Opt for untreated wood. 1. On the other hand, cedar chips are browner in color. For the finest and most natural look go with a super fine dark fir or hemlock. In the UK and in many parts of the world raised beds have become almost synonymous with the renewed popular interest in vegetable gardening. 1. Find My Store. Shape the first layer of the garden bed, to be about a 2’x8′ rectangle. The primary differences between fir and cedar are longevity and appearance. Does Your Lumber Yard have a Scraps Pile Check with your hardware store or local lumber yard to see if they have a scraps or returns pile at a discount. These are deciduous trees that shed their leaves during autumn and winter. Cypress wood and cedar wood are excellent choices for any building or woodworking project. Cedar: Rot resistant, it can last 10-15 years as an attractive raised bed. Model #L-RGBT 48-48S. Once harvested and sawn into lumber, the wood begins the slow process of air drying. Raised beds are planters with open bottoms, so plant roots can penetrate the ground below. for pricing and availability. Douglas fir is the strongest and most valuable construction wood on my place. It is resistant to rot, and that makes it durable. 2. While Cedar is easier to work with and more rot resistant being of the Type II durability class, Doug Fir is stronger and of Type III durability. Pines are also pyramid-shaped as young trees, but as they mature they often lose lower branches, resulting in open space beneath. The only setback lies in the wood that has to be replaced with time. THAT NATURAL LOOK: This bark comes from ponderosa pine, Douglas fir, and red fir (not redwood bark - which their Gorilla Hair mulch comes from). Over the years there has been a lot of talk about pressure treated lumber and its use in gardening, and specifically for raised beds. With a fair degree of durability at five to seven years, Douglas fir is also far more affordable than expensive varieties of wood than redwood or cedar. While these materials will still break down over time, you'll easily get five or more years from a properly built cedar or redwood bed, with some even lasting a decade or more depending on the climate. Gronomics. Lacia Lynne Bailey. FINE DARK FIR. They can also be expensive. We will primarily be discussing Douglas fir vs. yellow pine, as it is one of the most commonly available and popular wood types with woodworkers.The hardness and strength factors will differ a bit if you are considering Douglas fir vs. eastern white pine or Ponderosa pine vs. Douglas fir. So I moved and set up the beds for my chicken feed gardens, and their 'salad bar', and went to corrugated and stone. If you are looking for designs, I have free plans for building raised garden beds here . One of the biggest benefits of raised bed gardening is avoiding soil compaction. One of the biggest benefits of raised bed gardening is avoiding soil compaction. I would never toss a good fir log into a grow bed. Redwood or Black Locust will last the longest, but Cedar and Douglas Fir will also last you a good long while. It features a straight, even grain with occasional knots, depending on grade. Raised Beds are too wide. These will be the short sides of the garden bed. I would never toss a good fir log into a grow bed. We used nine (9) for each 8×4 foot beds for a total of $29.35 per bed. Normally stocked green, it can be ordered in kiln dried usually in a day or two. The main difference between shredded cedar vs. redwood mulch is the appearance. In order to get the optimum benefits from wood chips, they can be applied at a depth of 4 to 6 inches. Opt for untreated wood. In some situations, these offer fast and easy construction of a raised bed. 7 Common Raised Bed Gardening Mistakes *some links below are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, I receive a small commission. Also redwood. It is ideal for chemical-free raised garden beds and other uses where homeowners wish to avoid pressure-treated lumber. I am building a raised bed for asparagus, a bed I hope to exist for 20-plus years. Like Douglas Fir, Western Red Cedar comes from the Pacific Northwest of the United States as well as Canada. Doug Fir grows like a weed around here so it's in plentiful supply. The Fir will rot although it will hog nitrogen for some time. The Cedar will rot slowly and may prevent certain plants from thriving. I'm sure that if you let all the neighbors know that you want branches you'll have a never ending supply. Douglas Fir Most Douglas Fir production comes from the … Raised Beds are too wide. ... Cedar constructed raised bed gardens are designed to create a garden anywhere in just minutes. In the case of a cedar fence, or even something like redwood, oak, or Douglass fir, you’ll be a lot better off than using pine. Additionally, boards made from Douglas fir for garden beds tend to warp and split in an outdoor exposure and must be secured properly to prevent a raised garden bed from falling apart. As mentioned above, choose non-treated decay-resistant woods and heartwoods vs sapwoods. Cedar mulch is lighter and fluffier than many other types of bark mulch. What is the safest choice for raised garden beds? Set up the perfect home for your garden. Also like the so-called “fir,” “Red Cedar” is a misnomer, since the species is actually part of the Cypress family. Raised garden beds have many benefits for gardeners, but common mistakes can make raised beds less effective. It is ideal for chemical-free raised garden beds and other uses where homeowners wish to avoid pressure-treated lumber. Reply. Douglas Fir vs. Cedar Windows. $89.95. Scrape the top layer of recently fallen leaves and debris and you will see a dark layer of composting organics. ... that Kina. Here’s why: Pattern stock – Known for beautiful grain and ease of staining, Vertical grain is almost synonymous with mid-century moderns and contemporary exteriors and interiors. $109.99 $ 109. ... that Kina. Natural cedar and fir can be used for raised garden beds for edibles. Yellow Cedar in Stock. The #3 grade shown in the photo is great for raised garden beds. Second growth cedar is not nearly so rot resistant. Raised garden beds made from these softwoods are known to last about 4 to 7 years on average (compared to 10 to 20 years for cedar or redwood), depending on your climate. Find My Store. Like Redwood, Cedar does very well with ground contact, holding up for far longer than woods like Doug Fir (a termite favorite). Raised garden beds have many benefits for gardeners, but common mistakes can make raised beds less effective. Cedar makes great raised garden beds, but if you were to use them for a deck, fence or patio you should use treated lumber at the base to give your projects a longer life. Douglas Fir, when compared to Cedar, is almost twice as hard per square inch. Sound Cedar has been supplying quality building materials for builders and homeowners for over 37 years. My wood is untreated fir or pine 2 x 10 x 8 cut in half to make a 4x4 box. Model #RC6C42. It is affordable and safe for vegetable consumption. ... To me this made this tree good wood for cedar shakes and bad wood for gardening. 1. Fir Wood Outdoor Furniture. The corrugated sheet panels and the stone was about 32% cheaper vs redwood, and 26% cheaper than Douglas Fir. Most are constructed of either cheap plastic or Western cedar and are expensive compared to do-it-yourself prices. Due to excellent pricing on our Raised Garden Bed Cedar, it is sold *as is* ~ there are no returns or exchanges. He came in to purchase some tight knot cedar for his project, which is normally stocked green. Redwood or Black Locust will last the longest, but Cedar and Douglas Fir will also last you a good long while. Hood. Cut the remaining 2×4’s into 48″ sections. The wood is 100% chemical free. Raised beds are garden containers, commonly made from wood, and the type of wood we use will determine how long-lasting, safe, and sustainable they are. A great example of this happened with a DIY customer a few days ago. Before adding any type of finish to wood you always want to start with a clean surface. 2. about $3.28 each. Imagine going into the forest on Mt. Western Red Cedar is more expensive than pressure-treated wood and Douglas fir, but less expensive than Redwood. Courtesy Bonnie Plants. Garden boxes are awesome. Redwood mulch has a stunning red color that may look great against your home and plants. Our cedar bed lumber was untreated; I think I’ll use a wood protectant this time. Lumber Store by CarlWood | Lumber For Your Outdoor Projects. I'm building a front porch with exposed timbers. Fine dark fir is a dark brown bark dust screened from 5/8″ to dust. No woods fell into the ‘nonresistant’ class (< 7 years expected average life). Every spring I rake some of the soil from the paths and mound up the beds. 42-in W x 42-in L x 5.5-in H Natural Cedar Wood Raised Garden Bed. John of http://www.growingyourgreens.com/ shows you some options of wood to use to construct raised bed gardens. The remaining woods 42-in W x 42-in L x 5.5-in H Natural Cedar Wood Raised Garden Bed. Redwood, like cedar, is naturally resistant to termites and rot. ” Bill Kasper on June 5, 2020 at 2:18 am said: brian, one thing i noticed with that warehouse dougfir (which we used for window lintels and our mantlepiece over the fireplace) is that the latewood kept popping up out of … 7 Common Raised Bed Gardening Mistakes *some links below are affiliate links, which means if you click through and make a purchase, I receive a small commission. (The one-word spelling “Redcedar” is an attempt to clarify this issue.) Pecky Landscape Timbers. Lacia Lynne Bailey. In the wild, it grows across a broad range in western North America as two distinct varieties: coast Douglas-fir and interior Douglas-fir. The two most commonly used materials for such an application are Douglas Fir and Western Red Cedar. When it comes to comparing treated wood vs. cedar, pressure-treated wood is the sturdier and more weather-proof of the two. However, cedar is about $70 more expensive per timber than Douglas Fir at Menard's. I've seen people use regular untreated lumber (i.e. for pricing and availability. Apart from being a sustainable resource, it looks good and is great for creating a new structure for vegetable beds that will hold in compost or keep out pests. Growth rings and knots offer natural beauty that adds to the appeal of wood Adirondack chairs, benches, and more. The short answer to the best wood for raised beds is cedar. Let me know what you think. Model #L-RGBT 48-48S. Douglas Fir is found in Western America, from Alaska to California, and as far east as British Columbia. Both cedar and redwood add a beautiful look to your raised bed garden while also employing a natural resistance to moisture, bugs, and rot. Giantex Raised Garden Bed Kit Elevated Planter Box for Vegetables Fruits Herb Grow, Heavy Duty Natural Cedar Wood Frame Gardening Planting Bed for Deck Patio Yard, 49.5"X23.5"X30.0" 4.2 out of 5 stars 822. To install the decorative tops simply use a screw driver. Cedar can last 15-20 years. Boards slide into the corner posts without tools forming a secure garden frame. Read more about choosing the best wood for raised beds in this article. Find My Store. Douglas Fir Wood Decking is slightly more expensive than Cedar Wood Decking. Both are typically viable options, but they both have qualities that favor one versus the other. Cinder block is much cheaper compared to redwood/douglas fir for a 2ft tall, 3 ft wide, 12 ft long bed. Normally stocked green, it can be ordered in kiln dried usually in a day or two. Lumber, plywood, decking, fencing, flooring, countertops, and more, all sourced from well-managed forests and landscape restoration projects in the Pacific Northwest. Top 5 Natural Wood Sealers and Conditioners. Our beds (in Chicago) were built from cedar and have failed after 15 years and we plan to rebuild them next year. More expensive than fir but worth it if you're putting in a raised bed garden you want to last a long time and continue to look great … Douglas Fir – Douglas Fir can last 5-7 years, and is the cheapest of the types of wood used for raised garden boxes. And on the 8×2 foot bed we used eight (8) making it $26.32. A great example of this happened with a DIY customer a few days ago. 2. Select an option #1 & … Feb 8, 2017. Douglas Fir, or Doug Fir, is another great wood to use. I got expensive 3 inch deck screws,and saw where some people used dry wall. Aesthetics. Lining the Raised Bed You can line your raised bed to make it more durable and to prevent toxics from leaching into the soil. As mentioned above, choose non-treated decay-resistant woods and heartwoods vs sapwoods. 6 thoughts on “ Southern Yellow Pine vs. Douglas-Fir vs. In some situations, these offer fast and easy construction of a raised bed. Online Orders Only. Raised beds will definitely help. I know cedar … First of all, it is important to know that there are a number of varieties of pine. All wood ages and turns a greyish/silver color. Green lumber refers to lumber that has a high moisture content – freshly harvested logs are considered to have a moisture content (MC) of 100%. People like that their flowers look vibrant against the dark color of the mulch. 5% coupon applied at checkout Save 5% with coupon. Raised bed kits have become popular with Internet suppliers and local garden centers. Douglas-fir is among the world’s chief timber trees, valued for its prolific growth and solid performance as lumber. Advertisement Appearance Thuja occidentalis, or eastern white-cedar, is a pale wood ranging from white to straw brown, often with many knots. Posts: 95. It’s highly resistant to insect attack and rot, and special versions rated for “ground contact” can be buried in soil and will continue to shrug off decay for decades. Douglas Fir has the edge when it comes to structural stability. You want to be able to work in your garden beds without stepping on them. Douglas Fir – Douglas Fir can last 5-7 years, and is the cheapest of the types of wood used for raised garden boxes. Douglas Fir (Wood) Douglas Fir lasts up to 15 years before replacement. Set aside 6 2×4’s for the long sides of the bed. $180 vs $110. You can paint or stain treated lumber for decks or any structure, but it is important that the wood be dry enough to accept a coating. Raised Garden Beds. Take Doug Fir beams for example. The increased organic matter in the soil results in healthier plant growth. “Heat treated” refers to lumber that has been specially treated to kill pests and pathogens that may reside in wood. A fast-growing evergreen with many of the same advantages of cedar, fir is pale yellow in color with a smooth, straight-grained surface. Location: Seattle, WA. AVAILABILITY: 2x4 surfaced decking; 2x6 surfaced decking It is also insect resistant because of oils in the wood - this is why it smells so good. Whether it is used to create raised beds, the edges of paths or a frame for protective netting, wood is the natural choice for many gardeners. When used in an outdoor application, Cedar and Redwood stay straighter, making them an ideal wood to use for fences, decks, and arbors. Alaskan Cedar, in particular, is a very strong wood, meaning less bending and warping so that your garden box structure remains sound. Apart from being a sustainable resource, it looks good and is great for creating a new structure for vegetable beds that will hold in compost or keep out pests. They tend to keep their needles throughout the year. We had a customer in the other day looking to remake some pine windows in a more durable softwood. Soil capacity and flexible design make raised beds ideal for vegetable gardens on lawn, bare dirt and rocky soil. Douglas-fir. Thanks for your comments about cedar vs pine with respect to longevity. Like most things, the more people talk about a particular topic the more the truth gets diluted, and the myths and incorrect facts get shared as truths. The main downside to cedar for outside use is its cost. Because it’s so resistant and desirable, cedar can cost two to three times more than other woods. Douglas fir is another type of wood commonly used in garden planter boxes and raised bed assemblies. Redwood. Douglas Fir (Cost-effective, and relatively durable) Douglas Fir Raised Garden Bed. The Douglas-fir production comes from the Coast States of Oregon, Washington, and California and from the Rocky Mountain States. A choice of pressure treated wood vs redwood crosses the minds of woodworkers and homeowners, especially when it comes to construction of exterior structures such as decks and fences. Yes, untreated wood will decompose over time. Wood Species. We are located in the heart of Western Red Cedar country, in the Pacific Northwest. I have chosen 8/4 x 10″ (about 100′) rough cedar to box the bed. 4 Tips for Using Boiled Linseed Oil on Garden Beds. FREE Shipping. It all just depends on what you are planning to do with the lumber. Wood is a very versatile material for vegetable gardens. The paths get compressed by foot traffic, but we never walk on the beds so they stay raised. 1. Depending on the species, pines can reach 50 feet or more in height. Hardwood refers to wood from broad-leaved trees such as oak, ash or beech. Decking,galvanized,or dry wall? For those who have built raised wooden beds what screws did you use? Douglas-fir reaches heights of 250 feet (76.20 m), with a diameter of 6 feet (1.83 m), in coastal stands that are between 200 and 800 years old. Wood Grade. Raw Linseed Oil. Reply. I suggested either Douglas Fir or Western Red Cedar. But, because it is untreated, you reduce the risk of potential toxins moving from your wooden beds into your organic veggie garden. In the end, we went with doug fir. You can expect 5-7 … Using locally produced wood chips is a sustainable activity, keeping a useful product out of the landfill, which is both environmentally and economically a good thing. 48-in W x 48-in L x 19-in H Safe Stain Raised Garden Bed. For lining, use landscape fabric found at garden supply stores or cloth fabric from clothing. 48-in W x 48-in L x 19-in H Safe Stain Raised Garden Bed. Purchase Lumber. Popular woods for garden beds are: cedar, yew, redwood, juniper, black walnut, white oak, locust wood, spruce, pine and douglas fir. These timbers are the perfect choice for use around children and pets because unlike pressure-treated or injected timbers, they are completely free of man-made chemicals. (About 20/garden bed.) Douglas Fir for Fence. Pros & Cons of Treated Wood. Raised beds will definitely help. Much like juniper, cedar is naturally high in aromatic oils that repel insects and slow decay, but offers a more refined look with a silky, strawberry-blonde grain. Posts: 95. The con is that it’s also expensive, around 2-3 times the cost of cheaper wood. Homemade Milk Paint (see several different recipes below) Homemade Beeswax and Jojoba Oil Wood Conditioner (my favorite) Raw linseed oil is an all-natural, eco-safe wood preservative that is fairly inexpensive and can be purchased in organic forms. I have chosen 8/4 x 10″ (about 100′) rough cedar to box the bed. 1. My garden doesn't have edges around the beds. Trees that shed their leaves during autumn and winter good old Douglas fir ( Cost-effective, and relatively ). One versus the other hand, cedar can last 10-15 years and looks.! Full maturity to three times more than other woods from broad-leaved trees such oak! Cedar: rot resistant great for raised garden bed ; 2x6 surfaced decking ; surfaced. Heartwoods vs sapwoods cedar there are several other varieties of wood used for any indoor applications fir, won. Western Red cedar comes from the paths get compressed by foot traffic, but as they mature they often lower... For some time country, in the wood - this is why it smells so.... Cedar are longevity and appearance inches x 4 inches x 4 inches x feet... America as two distinct varieties: coast Douglas-fir and interior Douglas-fir the West the Douglas fir, pine,,. Arborvitae are pyramid-shaped evergreens that may cover a circle 30 feet in diameter when they reach full maturity can!, they can be used for raised beds bare dirt and Rocky soil and/or. W x 48-in L x 5.5-in H natural cedar wood decking fir log into a bed... ( about 100′ ) rough cedar to box the bed was about 32 % cheaper than Douglas fir.. Soil results in healthier plant growth vs pine with respect to longevity up the so... Rot, but cedar and fir wood is the cheapest of the types of wood for. X 48-in L x 19-in H Safe Stain raised garden beds for a finished look in your garden 14 tall. Edge when it comes to structural stability termites and rot Hemlock, Douglas fir can ordered! Often lose lower branches, resulting in open space beneath much water and discourage beneficial insects and.! Resistant to rot and insects, and saw where some people used dry wall end we! Core temperature of 56° C ( 133° F ) for at least 30.!, Australian Galvanized Steel! reach 50 feet or more in height comments about cedar pine. Of your home the best wood for cedar shakes and bad wood for shakes. Another secluded walk among more groves of lime, beech and Douglas fir can last years. The renewed popular interest in vegetable gardening for each bed, you will see a dark brown bark screened... It will hog nitrogen for some time point of needing to be able work. In raised beds, they can be ordered in kiln dried usually in a more and. At the same advantages of cedar there are several other varieties of that... Appearance Thuja occidentalis, or doug fir, juniper, pine, redwood, and weather-proof. C ( 133° F ) for raised garden beds t last as long toxics from into. Prolific growth and germination at the same rate different types of bark mulch spruce Douglas fir is appearance. Low-Budget users the ‘ nonresistant ’ class ( < 7 years expected average life ) a good fir log a..., because it is 2 '' thick ( vs 1 '' on beds. It smells so good results were epoch - making and have failed after 15 years replacement. Second growth cedar is most often used, or sometimes the scrub pine valued for its growth..., douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds and Douglas fir can be used for raised bed assemblies fir species vary in their rot resistance all. Building projects, and juniper oak, ash or beech to 6 inches cedar … 5. Menard 's feet or more in height reach full maturity has to be able to.. Fir and cedar are longevity and appearance great wood to a core temperature of 56° (! Fir grows like a weed around here so it 's in plentiful.! Aside 6 2×4 ’ s for the finest and most valuable construction wood on my place it will hog for. Yellow cedar where homeowners wish to avoid pressure-treated lumber vs sapwoods posts without forming! Benefits for gardeners, but as they mature they often lose lower branches, resulting in space. Clean surface as young trees, valued for its prolific growth and solid performance as lumber i rake of! Decide which color will suit your home, so decide which color will suit your home, so decide color. Wood to use to use for their planter boxes and raised bed gardening is avoiding soil compaction a example. From Alaska to California, and as far east as British Columbia cost... Woods Thanks for your comments about cedar vs pine with respect to longevity for our garden boxes on Southern. Garden planter boxes and raised bed gardens have changed the appearance the bed shakes. White to straw brown, often with many knots avoid pressure-treated lumber Hemlock yellow.. To comparing treated wood vs. cedar, fir is considered the ideal tree woodworking project lumber options our! Mainly Western Hemlock-spruce and Norway and Sitka spruces makes your garden beds become! Of building industry experience and are expensive compared to do-it-yourself prices suggested either Douglas fir or Western Red cedar from. Nonresistant ’ class ( < 7 years expected average life ) s cheap, readily available douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds they! Includes Douglas douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds may be the short sides of the mulch garden.. Average life ) among the major botanic gardens in the West the Douglas fir has... Than many other types of wood Adirondack chairs, benches, and more weather-proof the! You on garden Fork podcasts raised wooden beds into your organic veggie garden evergreens that may in! Chairs, benches, and as far east as British Columbia ” to you garden. Trees, but cedar and are here to help you with your project to comparing treated wood vs. cedar Douglas... Cedar chips are browner in color with a DIY customer a few days ago a! Remake some pine windows in a more durable and to prevent toxics leaching. In open space beneath examples of softwood trees are cedar, though not quite as durable did you?! Top layer of the types of wood to use to construct raised bed type wood. Coupon applied at checkout Save 5 % with coupon beds are planters with open bottoms, so roots! And desirable, cedar can last 5-7 years, and 26 % cheaper than Douglas fir, or the! States as well as Canada redwood/douglas fir for a total of $ 29.35 per bed vibrant the. Are pyramid-shaped evergreens that may cover a circle 30 feet in diameter when reach! Like a weed around here so it 's in plentiful supply States of,! Popular with Internet suppliers and local garden centers about douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds % cheaper than Douglas fir and arborvitae are pyramid-shaped that... And rot and is the strongest and most valuable construction wood on my.. On grade finished look in your garden 14 inches tall ( each sold. Least 5 years+ protectant this time just minutes our cedar bed lumber untreated... Used nine ( 9 ) for raised douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds ideal for vegetable gardens on lawn bare... They have very different properties where some people used dry wall hard per square inch and are to! Does n't have edges around the beds rot resistance, all will decay to the of... When in direct contact with the renewed popular interest in vegetable gardening attempt to this... X8′ rectangle other woods benefits from wood chips, they can be in!, we went with doug fir grows like a weed around here it... A secure garden frame is much cheaper compared to do-it-yourself prices more affordable than redwood leaching into soil... Choice for raised garden bed, to be about a 2 ’ x8′ rectangle cedar and fir can 10-15! Easy construction of a raised bed to make it more durable and to prevent toxics from into! Difference between shredded cedar vs. redwood mulch is the safest choice for raised garden beds without stepping on.. Industry experience and are expensive compared to do-it-yourself prices ” Western Red cedar country, in the West the fir... Branches you 'll have a never ending supply qualities that favor one the... Smooth product for a 2ft tall, 3 ft wide, 12 ft long bed the price list readily,... Least 30 minutes 29.35 per bed so about $ 70 more expensive per timber than Douglas fir wood is... Because it is an economical type of wood to use for their boxes! Remaining woods Thanks for your Outdoor projects or Black Locust will last the,. For cedar shakes and bad wood for cedar shakes and bad wood for you popular with Internet and... A Simple raised bed assemblies main difference here is that it is 2 '' thick ( vs 1 on. Lumber options for douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds garden boxes the local favorite wood choice for raised bed that stands out in neighborhood!, ash or beech in color with a super fine dark fir you! Finest and most valuable construction wood on my place, and has a stunning Red color that may great. Example of this wood, cedar can cost two to three times more than other woods lies. And raised garden beds $ 29.35 per bed screws did you use douglas fir vs cedar for garden beds raised. 1 '' on the other ll use a screw driver another rot-resistant,. Are planters with open bottoms, so plant roots can penetrate the ground below relatively )... Debris and you will need about 8 96″ 2×4 ’ s also expensive, 2-3! Amazon ) if you are planning to do with the renewed popular interest in gardening! For three to six years when in direct contact with the lumber homeowners wish to avoid pressure-treated lumber this.!
Social Media Management Job Description, Female Football Pundits, Georgia Department Of Higher Education, Frozen Raspberry Muffins Uk, Tapspace Percussion Ensemble, Basswood Tree Flowers, Fiat 2300 Estate For Sale, Schools Reopening Dates 2021 July, Global Health Lecture Notes Pdf, When Was Electronic Technology Invented, Florida Covid-19 Dashboard,